California Personal Injury Lawyers - Bakersfield Personal Injury Attorneys - Chain, Younger, Cohn & Stiles

OCT 2004


Proposition 64 - Limit on Private Enforcement of Unfair Business Competition Laws
Hot Topics
Avoid Foreclosure Scams
Group Law Service
Current Product Recalls
Other Chain Younger Websites
Free Case Evaluation

Proposition 64 - Limit on Private Enforcement of Unfair Business Competition Laws

California's Unfair Business Competition Law became effective in 1933 to protect consumers. Known as 17200 because it is in Section 17200 of the California Business and Professions Code, Proposition 64 is designed to make substantial changes to this law. This all came about because three unscrupulous attorneys in Beverly Hills (who have since been disbarred) misused the law to extract money from small businesses. Fortunately, the State Bar acted timely, along with Consumer Attorneys of Los Angeles and other consumer organizations, and stopped these guys in their tracks.

Here is a synopsis to help fully understand how this law affects you and how its abolishment will affect you and other consumers.

WHAT THE UNFAIR BUSINESS COMPETITION LAW (UBCL) DOES NOW:

  • It protects public health and the environment.
  • It is California's key consumer protection statute.
  • It's been used to punish polluters, stop misleading advertising, prevent religious discrimination and put a stop to unscrupulous financing schemes.

Lawsuits filed under UBCL, 17200 have:

  • Stopped oil companies from polluting drinking water.
  • Halted false advertising on raw milk.
  • Blocked tobacco billboards near schools.
  • Forced bottled-water companies to remove illegal levels of arsenic and bacteria.
  • Stopped a supermarket chain from changing expiration dates and reselling old meat.
  • Rid apartment buildings of lead paint.

WHAT WILL PASSAGE OF PROPOSITION 64 DO?

  • Make it more difficult for individuals to file lawsuits to halt illegal and unfair business practices.
  • Eliminate lawsuits that are currently filed in order to prevent an injury or harm from happening.
  • Eliminate almost all cases to protect the environment since most involve water, air or earth pollution, not lost money or property.
  • Mandate that only government prosecutors--not public interest organizations or institutional plaintiffs--can sue companies when they engage in practices prohibited under the UBCL.
  • Stipulate that in the future the proposed initiative cannot be amended by the legislature under any circumstances, even to further its purposes.

WHO'S BEHIND PROPOSITION 64?

  • The primary backer is the California Chamber of Commerce.
  • Financial supporters include corporations like Microsoft, Nike, Intel, Oracle, General Motors, Bank of America, Blue Cross, Safeway, Citigroup and State Farm-all companies that have been targets of lawsuits filed under UBCL, 17200. Combined, they have raised $13 million to promote this campaign.
  • The largest single financial backer is the California Motor Car Dealers Association.

WHO'S OPPOSED TO PROPOSITION 64?

  • Public health, consumer, and public interest organizations including the American Lung Association of California, AARP, California Nurses Association, Consumers Union and Sierra Club California.

WHY CHANGE THE LAW?

  • Supporters say the purpose of the initiative is to close a loophole that allows shakedown lawsuits and because attorneys are filing too many frivolous suits in the hopes of quick settlements.
However:
  • Safeguards are already in place against shakedowns and frivolous lawsuits.
  • No punitive damages are available under the current law, only an end to unscrupulous practices and an order that money be given back if someone was robbed.
  • Cases are decided by judges, not juries, which businesses say are too easy to convince.
  • There have been very few incidents of shakedown lawsuits reported to authorities.
  • UBCL, 17200 itself has been used to force unscrupulous lawyers who abused the law to give up their law licenses under threat of disbarment.

SUMMARY

The Los Angeles Times said in an editorial that "Proposition 64 would gut the state's tough Unfair Business Competition Law" and that "the all-or-nothing initiative risks throwing out the good with the bad."

California's Senior Assistant Attorney General Herschel Elkins says Proposition 64 "goes unbelievably far…Throwing out the baby with the bathwater is not the best thing. There are substantial problems with the proposal."

Proposition 64 is not about shakedown lawsuits or punishing a few unscrupulous lawyers, it's about posing a grave threat to California's workers, consumers, seniors, environment and the public's health and safety.

-Milt Younger, Senior Partner



HOT TOPIC

Avoid Foreclosure Scams

The possibility of losing one's home to foreclosure can be one of the most traumatic events in your life. Awareness of your options and being able to find assistance can alleviate a great deal of pressure off the family. It may also prevent even greater, future problems. If your house is currently in foreclosure, you may be targeted by unscrupulous businesses looking to take advantage of your vulnerable situation. Homeowners should be wary of any unsolicited visits by realty or property services. These visits can involve high-pressure sales pitches that can lead to the homeowner entering into disadvantageous or fraudulent contracts.

If your home is in foreclosure here are some steps to follow:
  1. Collect all pertinent financial information that may assist the mortgage company in making a decision.
  2. Call the mortgage company and relay your problems. Ask if they can modify or work out a catch-up program.
  3. If your mortgage is an FHA loan, contact the local HUD agency. If it is a VA, contact the Veterans Association. If your loan has mortgage insurance, contact the carrier for assistance.
  4. Consider consulting a realtor to sell your home and your CPA or attorney for possible tax consequences of foreclosure.
  5. Research a company with the Better Business Bureau www.bbb.org before you enter into any transaction involving your home.
  6. Do not sign any contract that contains blank terms or terms you don't understand.
For more information, please contact Group Law Service at 325-3425.



GROUP LAW SERVICE

Over 35 years ago, Chain-Younger pioneered Group Law Service to provide quality legal help for working people. Members of Group Law Service, and their immediate family, are entitled to free initial consultations, free notarized signatures (limit 3 per day) and reduced legal fees on most cases. We represent approximately 180,000 group members. If you would like to become a member of Group Law Service, click here.


Click Here for Current Product Recalls



You can visit Chain-Younger Websites for additional information regarding: